Showing posts with label langworthy. Show all posts
Showing posts with label langworthy. Show all posts

Tuesday, August 10, 2010

1889: The New Wife and Mother Apparently Succumbs









We now find ourselves quite solidly in 1889, and, as we already know, that as of 7 May a new trial had been granted to Valerie Wiedemann in her breach of promise and libel case against Robert Horace Walpole.

It didn't take long for the news to spread. Here's a brief from the Brisbane Courier dated Thursday 9 May 1889:

BREACH OF PROMISE. London, May 7.

Miss Wiedemann, who recently sued the Hon. Robert Horace Walpole, heir to the Earl of Orford, for breach of promise and seduction, has applied for a new trial, which was granted.
[It will be remembered that the Judge in the former trial ordered that a verdict for defendant be recorded, as the plaintiff refused to answer certain questions put to her in the witness box.]

The Walpoles have had a child, a daughter, and named her Dorothy Rachel Melissa Walpole. She was born in Kensington, London where her parents lived at 4 Queen's Gate Terrace, and she was baptized [the record is pictured, below left] on 15 April 1889 by an assistant curate, G. Bertram P. Coopland.

Just before that blessed event, however, readers on the West Coast of the U.S. had received upsetting news regarding the case and their own Louise Melissa Walpole [née Corbin]!

Here's a brief from the front page of the Pullman [Washington] Herald dated 13 April 1889:

From the time her child was born Mrs. Robert Horace Walpole, formerly Miss Louise Corbin of New York, has been very ill and her friends fear she cannot recover. Since the scandal between her husband and Miss Wieldman was exposed in court a few months ago she has been very nervous and in depressed spirits. Mr. Walpole is heir to the Earldom of Oxford.

Let's choose to ignore the facts that Wiedemann's name and Orford are both misspelled—likely the result of the effort of an over-zealous proofreader—and the fact that while her father, industrialist D.C. Corbin, had been born and raised in New York, Louise—born in Montana—had never been in the Big Apple as anything but a rich visitor. She'd been raised almost exclusively in and around the spas of Europe by her continually ailing mother, and never lived with her father.

What's striking is the fact that the article so calmly suggests that the young daughter of a local power broker may be close to death, at least according to unnamed friends. Now, I can easily see how the claim could be exaggerated, especially given that Louise had been raised by a woman who apparently never recovered from anything.

One can only imagine what was in the papers back in England. Was it a smokescreen planned to win back some of the sympathy that Wiedemann must have been currying through the writings of the Pall Mall Gazette, a newspaper that, while certainly not highly regarded [W.T. Stead of the Gazette was referred to by Matthew Arnold as a "feather-headed puppet of the New Journalism"], had apparently doubled its readership since it championed the cause of Miss Mildred Long in the Langworthy Case, and was presumably doing the same for Miss Wiedemann?

Still, the former Miss Corbin seemingly moved from a quite life on the continent alongside her perennially ailing mother into the midst of the latest scandal to hit the papers in a decade replete with them. She'd gone from eligible society girl to the public target of her new husband's crazed ex-lover. She'd heard from the seemingly unstable German ex-governess, "You know that I must curse you from the bottom of my heart, and that I do so, and shall do so in all eternity for the endless suffering you have brought over me, and also, you run away whenever I come. I shall meet you once, and you shall hear my curse." That couldn't possibly have sat very well with young Louise, likely still dreaming of marital bliss at that point. Or trying to.

The Walpoles apparently believed that Wiedemann had also written threats in chalk on their doorsteps and had followed the new Mrs. Walpole on the streets. Provocatively, a magazine portrait of the lovely new Countess of Orford had been defaced soon thereafter and left for her to find, having been scrawled insults such as, "Horrible, honourless girl," which I'll assume was a far more powerful condemnation of a woman than it might be today.

I've found the photograph at the top, right, of this entry [click it to enlarge] in an on-line portfolio of photographs grouped under the name "Walpole" by Life magazine. I believe this untitled, undated image is of Louise Melissa Corbin, and it is the portrait that had been torn from a supplement to Life magazine and defaced by Valerie Wiedemann. It was sight of this portrait, and its accompanying news, in early January 1888 that alerted her to Robert Walpole's engagement and upcoming nuptials.

Wiedemann's reaction may even have been the reason the couple was married at the English Embassy Church in Paris, and not in London or Norfolk, seat of the Orfords. But perhaps that had been the plan all along.

Let's just say that, despite my natural skepticism that this story may have been planted in the papers, it isn't very difficult to believe that Louise Walpole, suddenly the wife of an older man with what was quickly proving to be a checkered past, might have taken it all poorly and become ill.

1889 would be full of depositions, subpoenas, and preparation for proceedings that would not resume until over a year after Lady Dorothy's baptism. There would still be more strife between the legal teams before the second round of this match began, and, surprisingly, Valerie Wiedemann will have taken control of her own case inside the courtroom, representing herself, once the trial starts.

We'll see how that worked out for her next time…



Monday, August 9, 2010

Delving More Deeply into England, circa 1888







Yesterday we took a look into some of the context surrounding the Valerie Wiedemann v. Robert Horace Walpole trial of November 1888. It wasn't the first scandal involving England's upper crust in the 1880s, and certainly sent the decade out with a bang.

One case preceded it, however, is worth taking a slightly longer look at. We read last time that the Pall Mall Gazette had been "championing the application of Miss Wiedemann for a new trial in her case against Robert Horace Walpole, the heir to the Earl of Orford, for alleged seduction." The Gazette, as we know, was the organ that brought the Wiedemann affair into the public eye, notably the eye of Queen Victoria, who, upon hearing of Wiedemann's "misfortune," sent her 25 guineas.

This case follows a similar pattern to "The Langworthy Case," a proceeding that was still grinding its way through the High Court of Justice in August 1887.

Here are some more particulars of the Langworthy affair, presented here to provide once again some context for the Wiedemann v. Walpole case. It may even give some idea of what the expectations of the case might have been.

Here, first, is a summary of the case that appeared as noted:


THE LANGWORTHY CASE. Mr LANGWORTHY BROUGHT TO BOOK. HE PAYS ALL DAMAGES AND APOLOGISES.
Te Aroha News, Volume V, Issue 215, 13 August 1887, Page 4

A Reuters cable despatch received today announces that Mr. E. M. Langworthy, who has so long defied the English Courts, has at last been brought to book. The telegram is as follows:—

London, August 10. In the Langworthy case damages have been awarded to Mrs. Langworthy by consent. Mr. Langworthy apologises to the Court, and pays damages forthwith.

We assume that the damages referred to in this case are those for breach of promise of marriage. Mrs. Langworthy, after the marriage at Antwerp had been declared illegal, was advised by her solicitors to enter an action for breach of promise of marriage as the only way provided by law for punishing Langworthy for the fraud he had perpetrated upon her. The writ was served upon Mr. Langworthy in the Argentine Republic, but he treated it with the contempt he had shown to all the other orders of the Court. Judgment went against him, the amount of damages to be assessed in August before Baron Huddleston. Meanwhile the grip of the law, backed by a powerful public opinion, has been closing more firmly round the defiant Nabob. To protect himself against the judgments for alimony and costs, amounting to about £4,000 standing against him, Mr. Langworthy had got rid of £50,000 worth of property in England, and had suffered himself to be made bankrupt. But his troubles were not over. His sister, and his mother to whom the property had been transferred, were within reach of the Court and they were placed on the rack of examination. Mrs. Langworthy senior is a very old lady as well as very wealthy and she cannot take her property with her, and her beloved son would grieve above all things if it were left away from him. The suit commenced in the Argentine Courts had carried the war into his retreat. He was thus driven into a corner, and has collapsed. He has now humbly apoligised to the Court, and undertakes to pay all costs and damages forthwith. Justice is thus vindicated, and let us hope that a healthy public opinion in society will express itself unmistakably, and will show the man by sending him to Coventry that such offences as his cannot be atoned for by money wrung from him when resistance was of no further avail.


That summary report from New Zealand in the Te Aroha News, however, merely whets one's appetite to know more about the details of the case itself, one that surely influenced percetions about the Wiedemann v. Walpole proceedings, especially since it was also overseen by Baron Huddleston. In another article that appeared in the Ashburton Guardian on 29 September 1887 [seen, right], we can easily see at least one way in which the proceedings of this case affected Wiedemann v. Walpole: £10,000 had been spurned by the solicitors of Miss Long/Mrs. Langworthy as a settlement with Edward Martin Langworthy. That figure was obviously became the amount that Miss Wiedemann indeed intended to accept.


In a book entitled Further Indiscretions [Dutton: New York; 1918], written by "A Woman of No Importance," the anonymous author claims to have had the particulars of the affair related to her personally. Today, the website amazon.com credits Amy Charlotte Bewicke Menzies [also known as "Mrs. Stuart Menzies"] as the author. Assuming that's correct, here is the entire chilling and tragic scenario as framed in hindsight in that 1918 text by by Mrs. Menzies [with my emphases]:


Sensational trials are apparently very short lived in the public memory. Perhaps because they seldom have historical significance, although so full of human interest... The Langworthy case was remarkable chiefly as a record of villainy that to my mind seems almost unique, and leaves one dumbly wondering at the dark possibilities of cruelty that lie in the human heart.

It also shows the apparently anomalous case of a woman who first obtained a decree nisi with £1500 a year alimony from the Courts and subsequently £20,000 for breach of promise of marriage against the same man. The law is a wonderful institution.

The way I came to know so much about the case was through being asked by Dr. Godson, the great ladies' doctor of those days, if I would go and see a patient of his who was in great trouble and ill- health as well as practically penniless.

Of course I went, and from Mrs. Langworthy's own lips heard her pitiful story, which as it appears to have been entirely forgotten, I relate briefly.

The Mrs. Langworthy of the case had been a Miss Long, the daughter of well-to-do people in Ireland, her father being estate agent at one time to the Marquess of Downshire and later to Lord O'Neile.

She was a tall, handsome girl and gifted, as was proved by her passing in 1873 as one of the senior candidates at the Dublin University, taking honours in French, Latin, Euclid and Algebra.

Her composition on English literature was chosen as good enough to be read aloud by Professor Dowden. Fired with her success she then went to Cambridge, where she shone in Latin, Divinity, etc.

About this time her father lost most of his money, and Miss Long decided she would cost him nothing more and went out as governess. During a visit to Paris with her brother, who was staying at that comfortable old-fashioned Hotel Bedford, she met the man who was to ruin her life, namely, the exceedingly rich and not ill-looking Mr. Langworthy, with great estates in South America, a magnificently appointed yacht, French chef and all the luxuries and comforts which usually surround men with large fortunes. At the time he became enamoured of Miss Long he was a widower. His first wife, Lady Alice, sister of the second or third Earl of Limerick, died at sea in 1876, under what circumstances I do not know.

Mr. Langworthy proved a devoted if somewhat dictatorial lover, and an engagement quickly followed on their first meeting, but Miss Long was told under no circumstances must his mother know anything about it as she might disinherit him; the engagement must be a secret.

During this time he persuaded Miss Long to go for a little cruise in his yacht, having provided a suitable ballast of chaperonage. They stayed at Cherbourg for a day or two, and while there he introduced his fiancee to a number of people, including the Hon. Cecil Cadogan, Mr. Dennison and others. While at Cowes Mr. and Mrs. Vereker invited them to dinner. All was comfortable and plain sailing. One day Mr. Langworthy while at Cherbourg asked Miss Long to go for a drive with him to Caen; they looked at the cathedral
[pictured, below right] and then taking both her hands said, "I want you to marry me at once; I cannot wait any longer for you and have arranged everything." She was entirely taken by surprise and objected. While he pleaded she turned over in her mind all the circumstances, and feeling there could be nothing but love to influence him, as she was penniless except for her own earnings, consented, knowing nothing about French marriage law.

The carriage was told to stop before a Catholic Church some miles out in the country from Caen. Here awaited them (all having evidently been arranged) a priest in a black cassock and a fat, disagreeable smile, who read some sort of a service in Latin. As a matter of fact the whole thing was a fraud; seemingly such things can be arranged where money and villainy are not wanting. There were many interesting features in the story at this time, much too lengthy and complicated to relate here, but various thoughts came to her mind making Miss Long doubtful about the legality of this marriage ceremony, and suggesting that she would be happier with a second ceremony.

Mr. Langworthy, having had the legal training of a barrister, knew how to turn his knowledge to account, said, certainly if she wanted another ceremony she should have one. This time the chaplain of the American Seaman's Mission at Antwerp performed it, the divine's name being the Rev. Doctor Potts, a member of the Presbyterian Church.

What Mr. Langworthy knew and his unfortunate dupe did not know was that only civil marriages are valid in Belgian law.

However, in all good faith she had taken part in two ceremonies, the one near Caen in September, 1882, the second in January, 1883, at Antwerp. After this latter Mr. Potts entered the following in his register: —

''Antwerp, January 10th, 1883.—Edward Langworthy, England, widower, 35 years old. Mildred Pallise Long, Belfast (Ireland), maiden, 27 years old. Marriage ceremony by Rev. Arthur Potts."

This was duly signed by the witnesses, one being Mrs. Potts, the other a Mrs. Bailey, whom I think was acting companion, chaperon or something of the kind, I have forgotten what.

A copy of the certificate was handed to Mrs. Langworthy, but it was taken away by her husband, who said he would send it to his solicitors for safe keeping, and he would mark it private and important. He then made his wife promise to keep the marriage secret for a year as he did not wish his mother to know anything about it.

A happy time followed in the yacht; Mr. Langworthy seemed to be deeply in love with his wife; it was all glorious and the days chased each other like some love poems under sunny skies

They stayed a few days at Lisbon, where Mr. Langworthy introduced his wife to Lady Ashton, Lord Francis Cecil and others (this is a point to bear in mind).

From Lisbon, if I remember correctly, they sailed for Buenos Ayres, where Mr. Langworthy owned property. During the voyage his wife told him she expected to become a mother. From this moment his manner entirely changed and, instead of expressing pleasure, exclaimed, "We must put the little beast out to nurse." By degrees he now became so brutal it was forced upon her he was hoping his treatment, drugs and starvation, would kill the child, and possibly the mother also.

Driven nearly mad by his treatment, one evening she got out of her bed and went in search of her husband, threw her arms round him and implored him to say why he had so changed. He then told her not to make a fool of herself, she knew perfectly well she was not his wife and the child would be illegitimate, and as this had happened she must leave the yacht on reaching Buenos Ayres and go home again at once; if the affair became known it would be his ruin.

Without allowing her to land at their destination, he put her on board a French tramp steamer without a deck house, that having been washed away on its last voyage, and of course without either a doctor or stewardess.

Mrs. Langworthy begged for some baby clothes, and was given a box containing a few yards of flannel and calico, and £50 in her pocket and sent off home!

So back to England she came full of misery and shame with nothing to prove the story she had to tell but her wedding ring and the baby. Her pride would not let her seek her people, whom she knew would wish to help her but could not afford it. To use Mrs. Langworthy's own words to me, "When I first arrived I tramped London trying to find some clergyman to take up my case for me and see me righted; I could get help from none. One told me he had heard stories like that before and was sorry he could do nothing for me." Another, living in some state in Grosvenor Square, who preached regularly in a fashionable chapel not far from Berkeley and Grosvenor Squares, was sitting one evening after dinner before a comfortable fire sipping coffee from delicate china and toying with a gold spoon, surrounded by expensive fur rugs, books and comforts of all sorts, when Mrs. Langworthy sought his help and told her story. He did not rise from his chair while the poor woman poured forth her tale and implored him to help her. It was a wet night and she was wet through, having tramped the streets all day in hopes of finding some one to help her, her boots were worn through in places and her teeth chattered from cold and want of food.

She eventually was told he did not believe a word of her story, it was too impossible, but if it was true she must "Have faith."

Poor soul! She asked how that was going to find food for her child and herself and turned bitterly away. She described to me her despair as she once more walked along the wet pavements and meditated drowning herself and her child.
Passing down Conduit Street [left] she noticed a brass plate on a door with the name of Lumley and Lumley, solicitors, printed on it. She had not tried them, but would do so first thing next morning. She had already tried several solicitors, but she was destitute, friendless, broken in health, the law and the Church refused to help her, justice was her only weapon, while the whole force of the Langworthy's immense wealth was thrown into the scale against her.

The treatment meted out to her by the Anglican divines is a black and lasting disgrace to their Church and the system that produced them.

Her husband's relations would not listen to her, and this is the plight she was in when she entered the offices of Messrs. Lumley and Lumley in Conduit Street. They listened to her story, gave her money to go on with, took the trouble to collect the necessary evidence to prove the ceremonies that had taken place and undertook to fight the case for her. Magnificently they did it through all the courts for four years. Mr. Robert Lumley I do not remember meeting, but Mr. Theodore Lumley I am glad to have known, for he did for this defenceless, broken-hearted woman what not one single shepherd of Christ's flock would do.

Another revolting feature about the treatment from which this unhappy woman suffered, was the attitude of her own sex, the lodging-house woman where she lodged turned her out on hearing she was not living with her husband! Others treated her as if she was one of the lowest of those who walk the streets for their living. Even had that been the case, they should have shown some humanity to a suffering sister.

I did what I could for her, and by degrees one after another helped her; but that she got justice in the end and her life made possible during the long years while the case was in the courts is entirely due to Messrs. Lumley and Lumley, the solicitors, and to The Pall Mall
Gazette
, who took her case up warmly, collected money for her, published special editions of their paper with all the details of the case as it unfolded itself from day to day.

They also brought out a little booklet or pamphlet, entitled
A Romance of the Law Courts, Mrs. Langworthy's Trials and Triumphs
. Anyone wishing to read all the particulars of this extraordinary case cannot do better than get a copy and read it, if there are any now to be had.

Mrs. Langworthy's troubles were, however, not yet over, though the learned judges held her marriage to be illegal, but a marriage "in fact" and granted her £1500 alimony. Mr. Langworthy had fled to America, refused to pay and was nowhere to be found.

His solicitors and counsel worked indefatigably to delay any steps taken by Mrs. Langworthy's solicitors to obtain the money for her.

The husband's wealth was a terrible weapon. I have been told great London papers even refused, through the influence of Mr. Langworthy's agents, to insert her lines in their agony columns.

Goods of his, seized to pay his debts to his wife, were instantly claimed by his mother as her property and therefore inviolate. While all this was taking place Mrs. Langworthy was often in great need, and but for the kindly help of The Pall Mall
Gazette
and Messrs. Lumley and Lumley would surely have gone mad.

Twenty thousand pounds on paper did not help her much. Her husband was made a bankrupt, but he had made his English property over to his mother. In the end the victim triumphed, having fought hard for her child, but there was no getting away from the fact that the strain had told upon her considerably. She was aged and broken down at the end of the four years almost beyond recognition.

The end of these people was as tragic as their lives. Mrs. Langworthy rejoined her husband and forgave him, she died suddenly when in Paris with him and he committed suicide next day.

It is impossible to picture the state of a man's mind who could be so systematically cruel to a woman who had done him no wrong.

As I congratulated Mrs. Langworthy on her victory I felt a lump come into my throat, but I remembered her as she was when I first saw her in the early days of her trouble and mentally compared her with what she was after four years' hard fighting. She had won the day, but the heart, health and spirit to enjoy her triumph had gone. In a measure it was Dead Sea fruit.


Ironically, it's with an eye toward the life of Lady Dorothy Mills that we examine this case—one that bears some similarities to that of the one in which her father and mother found themselves embroiled at the time of her birth. The irony is that Amy Charlotte Bewicke Menzies was the author of not just a trio of gossipy memoirs under the pseudonym "A Woman of No Importance" [presumably appropriated from Oscar Wilde's 1893 play], but writer of a 1913 book on hunting entitled Women in Hunting the Field. Lady Dorothy and her mother were both noted for their enjoyment of the outdoor sports of hunting and fishing, and the former in particular enjoyed a life of relative fame by continuing to do things that were usually done by men.

And, casting one more glance at the world of 1888, in which we find the scandalous and painful legal wrangling between Valerie Wiedemann and Robert Walpole only beginning, let's find even more context.

Thomas Hardy, Herman Melville, Henry James, Jules Verne, H. Rider Haggard, Rudyard Kipling, Robert Louis Stevenson, and Oscar Wilde were all published during 1888, as was Richard Francis Burton's translation of A Thousand Nights and a Night.

Gilbert and Sullivan's The Yeomen of the Guard, or The Merryman and his Maid, began its run at the Savoy Theatre on 2 October 1888, Pyotr Ilyich Tchaikovsky opened both his ballet Sleeping Beauty and Symphony No. 5, and works by Edvard Grieg, Claude Debussy, Richard Strauss, Gustav Mahler, and Nikolai Rimsky-Korsakov also debuted.

Georges-Pierre Seurat completed the pointillist Post-Impressionist masterpiece Les Poseuses [seen at right, above] and Paul Gauguin painted Vision After the Sermon (Jacob Wrestling with the Angel), while an unknown Dutch artist named Vincent van Gogh painted his famous Cafe Terrace at Night, Le Café de nuit, and La Chambre à Arles, as well as beginning his landmark sunflower series.

Heinrich Rudolf Hertz discovered radio waves, the International Exhibition of Science, Art, and Industry was held in Glasgow, Scotland, and the global atmospheric temperature finally returned to normal, five years after the eruption of Krakatoa in 1883.

The Football League was formed, as well as the Lawn Tennis Association. The Local Government Act of 1888 gave women the right to vote in local elections and Annie Besant organized the London Matchgirls' Strike.

And, finally, from 7 August through 9 November, the bodies of five prostitutes were found murdered, all attributed to the infamous "Jack the Ripper." The 'notorious districts' of London hadn't cornered the market on this sort of crime, however: On 2 October 1888, a box with the dismembered torso of a woman was found in a box inside of a relatively new vault beneath Scotland Yard, a crime dubbed "The Whitehall Mystery." None of the above crimes were ever solved.

Across England, the Reverend Barton R. V. Mills was vicar at Pouhghill in 1888, having just returned from San Remo after the devastating earthquake, and was raising his one-year-old son, Arthur Frederick Hobart, along with his first wife, Lady Catherine Hobart-Hampden.

And, also in 1888, Robert Horace Walpole had married Louise Melissa Corbin, daughter of an American multimillionaire, who was by the time of the November trial five or six months pregnant, carrying Arthur Frederick Hobart Mills's future wife, Dorothy Rachel Melissa Walpole.

That's where we find ourselves as we sit on the cusp of the second version of Wiedemann v. Walpole.

So, as American footballer Terrell "T.O." Owens would say, "Getcha popcorn ready." It's bound to be an interesting time…



Sunday, August 8, 2010

A Victorian Landscape of Adultery, Scandal, and Divorce








Having waded through texts of the first Wiedemann v. Walpole [not pictured] trial in 1888, we stopped to take a look at the particulars wearing the silks and wigs of the British courts at the time. And, we've primarily read coverage from the London Times, a paper that documented the courtroom scene in great detail, but provided little or no context for the proceedings.

Today, one needs to head "out of town" to gain some insight into what happened before the judge, Mr. Baron Huddleston, entered the courtroom on 29 November 1888 to hear that case. The events in Victorian society leading up to the case still can, even over 120 years later, be teased out of the internet, providing us with a great deal of context.

Here's a good start: It's an article from the Brisbane Courier on Monday 7 January 1889, after Valerie Wiedemann's proceedings against Robert Horace Walpole had been ended acrimoniously at the close of the previous November. It reads:

A ROYAL GIFT. London, January 4. A report was recently published that the Queen had presented 25 guineas to Fraulein Wiedemann, the German governess, who recently sued the Hon. Robert Horace Walpole, heir to the Earl of Orford, for breach of promise of marriage and seduction, the case being dismissed. It now transpires that her Majesty sent the money to Miss Wiedemann on first hearing of her misfortune, and before the trial took place.

Having stumbled across this brief article months ago, it weighed on my mind. I wondered: Why would Queen Victoria have sent her anything? Had she been moved by Miss Wiedemann's unfortunate story? And if so—and this is what I simply could not seem to work out—how had it come to the ear of her Majesty?

Recently, the following rather caustic article, written without any apparent knowledge of paragraphing, was found in the Melbourne Argus of 5 January 1889. I doubt that anyone would exhibit this piece as to a class of young journalists learning the profession [unless they worked for Hearst], but it provides interesting, pertinent, and extremely useful information I've been unable to unearth elsewhere. Here it is in its entirety:

A sensational breach of promise case was commenced on Wednesday, but collapsed ignominiously on Thursday morning. The plaintiff was a German governess named Valerie Wiedemann, and the defendant was Mr. Robert Horace Walpole, the nephew and heir of the octogenarian Earl of Orford, Mr. Robert Walpole has been connected with English diplomacy in various ornamental capacities for 10 years past, chiefly on the staff of his cousin, Sir Henry Drummond Wolff. In the course of his duties he found himself at Constantinople in 1882, where he lost his heart to the governess of his hotelkeeper's children; and the usual kind of Constantinople romance followed. The lady—who states that in consequence she became a mother—eventually found her way to England, where she became governess in the family of Lord Walter Campbell, to whom she imparted the story of her wrongs and her ruin. One would have supposed that any of the Campbells would have an instinctive aversion from law and the law courts; but it was not so in Lord Walter's case; and he promptly took his fair protégé to Mr. Stead [pictured, right] at the Pall Mall Gazette office, where her story was duly put into type. At one time it was contemplated to make the case a repetition of the Langworthy case, and that, as it now turns out, would have been the wiser course, but instead, law proceedings of the usual type were decided on and commenced. Unfortunately, the plaintiff appears to have caught the infection of "not swearing up to her proof," which has broken out so virulently among The Times witnesses in the neighbouring Probate Court; and in cross-examination, she carne to a full stop, refusing to answer any questions about her child and was ordered out of Court by Baron Huddlestone, the jury binding a verdict for Mr. Walpole. Mr. Walpole, who is a handsome young man, with the usual F.O. repose and insolence of manner, married last spring the daughter and heiress of Mr. Corbyn, one of America s railway kings. He and his fiancée were led a terrible life of it before and after their marriage by fear of the outraged governess and her vengeance. It is believed that a thousand pounds would at any time have set the matter quietly at rest; but this Mr. Walpole would not give, for he is "close," and, more over, obstinate; and in thus resenting interference with affairs which he considered peculiarly his own, he has only been imitating the example of the uncle, Lord Orford, whose heir he is. That ill-regulated nobleman it was who carried off the wife of the last Duke of Newcastle but one, when his Grace was Earl of Lincoln. Mr. Gladstone was the colleague, friend, and trustee of the injured lord, and he took upon himself to follow the guilty couple over Europe with a view to obtaining evidence which would enable his friend to obtain a divorce. In one of the smaller German principalities Lord Orford, finding Mr. Gladstone's attentions rather troublesome consulted a local lawyer as to how he could get rid of them, and the local lawyer advised him that if he would prefer a claim for debt against Mr. Gladstone, the latter would be at once locked up until he paid or proved conclusively to the highest court in the principality that he did not owe the money. Lord Orford was much pleased with the idea, which he at once adopted—poor Mr. Gladstone lying in durance vile for two or three days until the lovers were well out of ken, when orders were sent by Lord Orford to withdraw the charge against him. The part which Mr. Gladstone took in the Lincoln-Orford divorce case was often thrown in his teeth when, in 1857, he was opposing, tooth and nail, Lord Westbury's bill for cheapening and popularising the process of divorce.


Apparently the case had been brought to the public's attention by the Pall Mall Gazette, a newspaper who had recently sensationalized a similar case involving breach of promise, seduction, illegitimacy, and abandonment by Mr. E. M. Langworthy. It took four years for the duped Mrs. Langworthy to find justice, and that case had just concluded in London on 10 August 1887 [We'll take a closer look at that affair soon]. The Langworthy case would seemingly still have been fresh in the minds of Londoners as the Gazette began another series, this time based on breach of promise, seduction, illegitimacy, and abandonment by Walpole.

Other names flicker in and out of the article immediately above.



Sir Henry Drummond Wolff [left] is mentioned, although he seems to have no involvement save the fact that it was while Walpole, his cousin, was assigned in an "ornamental" capacity to Wolff, that the indiscretions involving Wiedemann occurred. That also seems more than a small slap at Walpole.

Lord Walter Campbell, who had been a merchant as well as having been titled as Duke of Argyll, is mentioned as the employer and benefactor who brought Wiedemann's case to the attention of the Gazette.

The article snidely remarks that: "One would have supposed that any of the Campbells would have an instinctive aversion from law and the law courts." This, apparently, alluded to the fact that in the press at that very time, Lord Campbell had been beset by marital difficulties brought on by the infidelities of his wife, affairs that he steadfastly refused to address via divorce.

The New York Times of 10 May 1914, in recounting Lord Campbell's unhappy marriage, stated:

Lady Walter Campbell's loveliness was equaled only by her indiscretions, and on a memorable day Lord Walter abandoned her in Biarritz, taking away their two children from her, informing her that he washed his hands of her forever, and that if he refrained from instituting divorce proceedings against her it was because he did not wish to furnish a second chapter to the disgraceful story of the matrimonial experiences of his brother, the late Lord Colin Campbell, or to tarnish the escutcheon of the Dukedom of Argyll with another great public scandal.

Shortly afterward, Lord Walter, who had been passionately devoted to his wife, sailed for South Africa in search of a change of scene, leaving his children with his father, the eighth Duke, at Inverary Castle. But he died [at the age of 40] within a fortnight of landing at the Cape.

In a Biography of Lady Campbell [pictured right, born Gertrude Elizabeth Blood in May 1857], it's noted that back "in October 1880 she visited family friends staying in Scotland and met Lord Colin Campbell, MP and youngest son of the 8th Duke of Argyll. Within three days they were engaged, and despite his family's objections they married the following year. As Lady Colin Campbell, she was launched into an elevated social circle where she enjoyed the company of royalty, eminent politicians, and famous characters from the world of literature and art. But all was not well at home, as the couple's incompatibility became glaringly apparent. Despite desperate family attempts at mediation the marriage broke down [in 1884] irrevocably and ended up in the dreaded divorce courts [in 1886]. She accused him of adultery and cruelty. He accused her of adultery with four co-respondents and scandalised society with such a suggestion. A Duke, a general, a doctor, and a fire-chief were all named by Lord Colin in his thirst for victory in what was to become the longest divorce trial in English legal history.

After the acrimonious trial the couple went their separate ways. Lord Colin was indebted, embittered, and an embarrassment to his prominent family."

The widespread reverberations of all of these painful events must still have been clearly felt in London courtrooms as Wiedemann v. Walpole loomed in 1888. It's easy to see why Lord Campbell avoided his own time in court, but would have wanted to reach out and help another seemingly broken-hearted soul, ironically just months before his own tragic and untimely passing.

Finally, the article refers to Gladstone, the Duke of Newcastle, and Walpole's uncle, Lord Horatio Walpole, the 4th Earl of Orford. It's fairly descriptive of the suggested scenario, but leaves out the fact that the Duke of Newcastle had been influential in Gladstone having been elected to Parliament in 1832 as M.P. for Newark. Gladstone clearly had extremely close ties to the Duke, with whom he'd attended Oxford.

In a brief biography of Henry Pelham-Clinton, the 5th Duke of Newcastle under Lyne, on the website of the University of Nottinghham, it relates the following [my emphases]:

Newcastle's personal life was unfortunately rife with unhappiness. His marriage was fraught with difficulties and ended in divorce in 1850. His relationship with his father was strained, particularly in later life as the political beliefs of father and son became increasingly divergent, as were his relationships with most of his children.

In 1832 he married Lady Susan Hamilton Douglas (1814-1889), only daughter of the 10th Duke of Hamilton and they had five children.

T
heir marriage was not a success and they were divorced in 1850 after a considerable scandal as his wife, who was considered by some to be mentally unstable, eloped and had an illegitimate child (Horatio Walpole) by Lord Horatio Walpole [left] (later 4th Earl of Oxford [sic]). She later remarried in 1860 M. Jean Alexis Opdebeck of Brussels.

The Argus article of 5 January 1889 makes it clear that they considered the behavior of Robert Horace Walpole almost a family trait, writing: "He has only been imitating the example of the uncle, Lord Orford, whose heir he is." Apparently, after the elopement of his uncle with an unstable married woman and siring of an illegitimate son with her, the Argus simply is less than shocked by young Robert Walpole's similar behavior. In fact, the anonymous author insultingly states that Walpole's "close" and "obstinate," but seemingly takes little issue with Walpole's actual behavior toward Wiedemann.

Oh—and what does "
F. O. repose" mean?

Anyway, the landscape of British society in the early 1880s seems to have been littered with a plethora of the closet skeletons of the well-to-do and the peerage. Perhaps, coming on the heels of these other scandalous cases, Walpole's alleged seduction, rape, impregnation, and abandonment of Frau Wiedemann became a case of "been there… done that" among the public and the courts.

Still, reaction wasn't entirely blasé in London at the time. Here's an extremely brief article from the Northern Territory Times and Gazette dated Saturday 22 December 1888:

The PALL MALL GAZETTE is championing the application of Miss Wiedemann for a new trial in her case against Robert Horace Walpole, the heir to the Earl of Orford, for alleged seduction.

We already know that Wiedemann had been granted a mistrial. Interestingly, here's how it was reported in a column called "TOPICS OF THE DAY [From Our London Correspondent]" in the Star, New Zealand, dated 26 June 1889:

MISS WIEDEMANN'S GRIEVANCES. The Court of Appeal has granted Fraulein Wiedemann's application for a new trial, so we may after all get to the bottom of the young lady's peculiar relations with Mr. Robert Walpole. It is worth remarking that, though the Walpoles loudly expressed regret at the first trial's falling through and said they could have proved this, that and the other had it gone on, they nevertheless opposed Miss Wiedemann's application for a re-hearing tooth and nail. We were also shown the line which they now mean to take up, as the Solicitor-General hinted the unfortunate girl had become mentally irresponsible. Miss Wiedemann's friends will surely take care, after this timely hint, to present her in the witness-box cool, calm and resolved not to be made angry.

One needs only to read a few lines below that snippet to be reminded of how tragic the entire Wiedemann v. Walpole case was fast becoming. Here's another blurb, ironically in the very same column, under the sub-heading "LORD WALTER CAMPBELL'S DEATH." It states:

Poor Lord Walter Campbell never quite got over the shock of his wife's elopement. He had been in poor health for some time, but it was hoped the business trip to the Transvaal would put him right. It seems, on the contrary, to have killed him. Like most of the Campbells, Lord Walter was "something in the City," or, in other words, earned a fair income as a " guinea pig" of the reputable sort. After the Colin Campbell esclandre, the family could not stand washing more dirty linen in public, and no proceedings for divorce were in consequence taken against Lord Walter's wife.

These words were printed about Walter Campbell of Inverary Castle [right] in 1889 on 26 June, via the newspaper's London correspondent. Earlier, on 11 March of the same year, Louise Melissa Walpole, Robert's relatively new bride, had given birth to a daughter, Dorothy Rachel Melissa Walpole.

It was into this landscape of adultery, scandal, and divorce among the rich and famous that our Lady Dorothy Mills had been born. To think that it hadn't colored the world in which she was raised, both at home and around England, would be naive.

Next time we'll take just a little closer look at that world into which she was born, particularly the now seemingly forgotten particulars of the Langworthy case mentioned above. Until then, please add anything you can to this context for the proceedings of Wiedemann v. Walpole, or the life of our young Dororthy!